With each new generation of believers, there
seems to come a debate about the nature of salvation in regard to Israel and
the church. Along with that come certain hermeneutical questions about what, if
anything, the scriptures have to say about the future of ethnic Israel. From
Bible conferences, to Hollywood movies, to seminary cafeterias this is a hotly
debated topic. It seems in recent years that the literature has only increased
and the debate has only intensified, as the gap between certain positions seems
to widen. One does not have to watch cable news very long, or attend a
Wednesday evening prayer meeting at a local Baptist church, before the
conclusion is reached that people know they are supposed to think something
about Israel but they are not always sure exactly what it is.
One of the most important
passages in this discussion is Paul’s statement in Romans 11.26:
And in this way all Israel will be saved (ESV).
What does Paul
mean when he writes that all of Israel will be saved in the end?
Survey of
Viewpoints
Some argue that
Paul is claiming that all Jews for all of history will be saved when it is all
said and done. This is clearly not the case because the scriptures and history
are filled with Israelites that have rejected Christ. There are many Jewish
people today that reject that Jesus is the Christ.
Others argue that Paul is stating
that all living Jews at the time of the Second Advent will be saved. This also
seems unlikely. One of the keys themes pertaining to the people of God throughout
redemptive history is that there is always a believing remnant and a rejecting
remainder. Paul says that, “not all who descend from Israel belong to Israel”
(Rom. 9.6). And later he quotes Isaiah saying, “only a remnant of them will be
saved” (Rom. 9.27).
A third view
teaches that a large number of ethnic Jews will be saved at the second coming
of Jesus. This is the viewpoint of Tom Schreiner. This view is respectable but
I remain unconvinced. You have to remember that Romans 11 does not exist in a
theological vacuum. Rom. 9-10 precedes it. The message of Rom. 9 is that even
though most of Israel has rejected Christ, God is still saving some in his
sovereign mercy. Jews, as a people, are not beyond redemption. The message of
Rom. 10 is that the message of salvation is the same for all men. “Everyone who calls on the name of the Lord
will be saved” (Rom. 10.13). There is no soteriological division between
Jews and Gentiles; they are “one new man”
in Christ (Eph. 2.15). All people are saved by grace through faith (Eph.
2.8-9). Because this is true it seems antithetical that God would save both
Jews and Gentiles through the gospel until the time of the second coming when
he will save a large number of ethnic Jews en masse simply because Paul said
it. Since the resurrection of Christ the only avenue of salvation is through
the preaching of the gospel to all men everywhere (Mt. 28.18-20).
A fourth view is
that in Rom. 11.26 “all Israel” refers to the new Israel of God, the church.
This is the view of NT Wright. This view is incredibly persuasive and has
biblical precedent. There is no doubt that the New Testament reinterprets the
nature of the people of God so that it is not merely ethnic Jews but now all
who are in Christ are the Israel of God (Gal. 6.16). Matthew’s gospel makes it
clear that Jesus is the true Israel and all who trust in him are in turn
members of the true Israel. The hopes and promises of Israel are fulfilled in
the singular seed of Abraham, which is Jesus (Gal. 3.16). And now all who
belong to Jesus inherit those blessings (Gal. 3.29; Eph. 1.3). But this does
not necessarily mean that Paul is discussing the new Israel of God in Rom.
11.26. In fact, I believe it is ethnic Israel to which he is referring.
Rom. 11.26
Refers to All Ethnic Jews Who Trust in Christ During the Period Between His Two
Advents
The fifth view
is that Rom. 11.26 refers to all ethnic Jews who are saved during the two
advents of Christ. This is the view held by Sam Storms and GK Beale. I believe
this to be the correct understanding. In Rom. 9 Paul is clearly speaking about
ethnic Jews when he writes about his “kinsmen according to the flesh.” He ties
them to Isaac (v. 10) and Jacob (v. 13). And also distinguished between those
ethnic Jews that believe and those who do not (v. 6). He begins chapter 11 by
noting that he himself is an ethnic Jew and that God has not rejected him (v.
1). It only follows logically then that he would be discussing ethnic Jews in
verse 26 because this is what he has been discussing in the context of chapters
9-11.
Paul also
contrasts ethnic Jews with ethnic Gentiles in verses 11-24. Salvation has come
to the Gentiles (v. 11) and they have been grafted in to Christ (v. 17). This
is clearly not talking about spiritual gentiles, who are those who reject
Christ, but ethnic Gentiles. It follows that in this chapter Paul is not
discussing spiritual Israel, which is all who are in Christ, but ethnic Israel.
Because Paul is writing about ethnic Jews in this passage and not spiritual
Israel let me give a few reasons as to why I believe he is discussing every Jew
who believes the gospel during the interadvental period and not a large number of
ethnic Jews at the end of the age.
The
Salvation of all of Israel Began with the Ministry of Paul
In Rom. 11.13-16 Paul ties the
salvation of these Israelites to his ministry. The rejection of Israel has led
to the salvation of the Gentiles. The salvation of the Gentiles, in turn, makes
Israel jealous and brings her to Christ. Paul is the minister to the Gentiles
and also his work is bringing salvation to Israel. If verse 26 were an
eschatological en masse salvation then it would have nothing to do with the ministry
of St. Paul. But Paul himself says that this work is tied to his ministry. In
fact, Jews did begin to believe the gospel of Jesus when Paul was preaching and
planting churches and his letters still bring some ethnic Jews the message of
the gospel today. There is no doubt that Israel’s salvation throughout church
history has been tied to and benefitted from Paul’s ministry.
The Riches
for the Gentiles
In verse 12 of
chapter eleven Paul says that the rejection of Israel has brought riches to the
Gentiles and that their inclusion will bring even more riches. Again, if the
phrase in verse 26 refers to a large-scale end-times salvation then how will
this bring riches to the Gentiles? If then Jesus will have returned to raise
the dead, judge the world and make all things new then surely all attention
will be on him. But if he is speaking to the salvation of Israel throughout
history then that certainly has, and will continue to, bring joy to the
predominantly Gentile church. There is great joy in the people of God when a
Jewish rejecter of Christ repents of their sin and trust in the righteousness
of Jesus!
The Nature
of Salvation
If Rom. 11.26 teaches that
a substantial number of ethnic Jews will be saved at the end of the age because
of their ethnic Old Testament heritage, then Paul’s teaching here is
antithetical to his teaching of salvation by grace through faith in the gospel
of Christ that permeates the rest of his writing. In the preceding chapter,
Romans 10, Paul teaches that all men are saved through the preaching of the
gospel.
14 How
then will they call on him in whom they have not believed? And how are they to
believe in him of whom they have never heard? And how are they to
hear without someone preaching? 15 And how are
they to preach unless they are sent? As it is written, “How beautiful are
the feet of those who preach the good news!”
Ephesians 2-3
teaches that all men are saved by the gospel of Christ and that the dividing
wall between Jews and Gentiles has been destroyed. If they are now “one new man” with the same hope then why
would the Jews be singled out again with a unique salvation experience at the
end of the age? The gospel is “the power
of God for salvation for everyone who believes, to the Jew first and also to
the Greek” (Rom. 1.16).
What is not
contradictory is the understanding that Paul is teaching that the Jews are
saved in the same manner as the Gentiles. All of Israel will be saved through
the preaching of the gospel and through belief in the promises of God that have
been fulfilled in Christ.